(Jenny thinks he and the other younger ones have forgotten and do not recognize her, but the visual cues leave it decidedly open-ended). As she crosses a park, she sees David with his new family, which he now accepts as his own. As she walks to an art class, she gives a voice-over expressing love and gratitude toward her three mothers: her birth mother, whom she misses Julia, who gave her a chance at a new life and her new mother, who is providing her with everything she could ever want. She has begun to talk and seems well-adjusted and happy.
In comparison, Jenny lives in a beautiful home, where her art is encouraged, and she has the best of everything. The police have given up on finding the children, thinking that Julia buried them in the tunnels which run for miles and are dangerous to traverse because of cave ins, etc. In Cold Rock, Jenny's birth mother grieves over her runaway daughter, the town continues to decline, and Julia sits in prison. The Tall Man refuses payment, saying that the organization faces massive risks to rescue each child, with Julia martyring herself to save the organisation, which "rescues" young children from bad homes and places them with good ones, in an attempt to break the cycle of poverty and abuse which passes from one generation to the next. He then delivers her to a new family, with a new identity. He takes her to an empty house in a nearby city, providing her with new clothes. Disgusted, Jenny walks off into a nearby field, where she finds the Tall Man waiting for her-Julia's husband, who is not dead after all. Soon after, Jenny watches her mother engage in a drunken fight with her boyfriend, before laughing with him over it. Julia admits to kidnapping and murdering the children, but the confession is later revealed to be a lie. The nanny hangs herself, and Julia is taken to jail, where she is despised and threatened as a child killer. The police and FBI arrive, as does an angry mob. Julia initially refuses but then relents, cautioning her to remain silent about it until the Tall Man comes for her. Jenny begs her to send the Tall Man to take her, too. Julia, with the help of Jenny, pursues the mother, reacquires David, and hands him off to "The Tall Man" in the tunnels which run under the town, left over from the defunct mine. The rest of the town, skeptical of the mother's accusations, agree to give her a chance to prove her claims.
The kidnapper is actually the real mother of the boy, attempting to take back her child. While in pursuit of what the viewer believes is "The Tall Man", it is gradually revealed that David is not her son at all, but rather one of the kidnapped children. She finds the nanny bound and gagged, then rushes to her son's bedroom, finding him gone. She awakes to a noise downstairs, followed by a loud radio sermon. She eats dinner, puts David to bed, and falls asleep on a couch. Julia returns to her large home on the outskirts of Cold Rock, which she shares with her son David and his nanny. This is a local legend or urban myth surrounding a being who abducts local children who are never seen again. She also sketches things she's seen, including "the tall man". Because of her rough life, Jenny is selectively mute, communicating through a journal she carries. Instead, she sends away Carol and her baby, whom Julia helped to deliver. Despite this, their mother did not kick him out, drawing Julia's ire. Jenny and Carol live with their mother and her violent, alcoholic boyfriend, who has impregnated Carol.
During her day, Julia visits several families. There is little work, the school has been closed and the town has virtually vanished from the map. Cold Rock was formerly a prosperous mining town, but has become poverty-stricken. She is the town's local nurse, widowed by her husband, who was the town's doctor. Julia lives in a small town in Washington called Cold Rock.